Friday, September 28, 2018

Urgent Need for Citizenship Education


We live in a republic where government depends on the actions of its citizens for its authority.  The Declaration of Independence says, explicitly, that governments derive “their just powers from the consent of the governed”.  To make this work most effectively, citizens must be informed on how the US government is structured, and on the norms and rules that guide good faith implementation of policy and law.

Yet, our schools very often require no education in civil government, no instruction on what it means to be a citizen.  We spend lots of money and energy on STEM education but little on creating informed citizens who are equipped to make choices on those who represent us.  It may come as a surprise to many but the structure put in place 231 years ago by our founders required, in James Madison’s words, application of “political science”.

Our founders created a design for government that was truly an innovation.  It was based on the principle that we are all equal before the law, and have inherent rights bestowed on us by our Creator.  Government is created to supply order and structure, and security, to its citizens, and the citizens give up some of their individual rights to empower the government to carry out its functions.  That government maintains its role so long as it fulfills its ability to secure the Life, Liberty and Happiness of its citizens.

To make choices on such an important matter - how we are governed (not ruled) and by whom- citizens must be well informed.  They need a solid grounding in the principles that are the foundation for our “government of laws, not men”.  Each citizen should be able to make an autonomous decision, taking all views into consideration.  They should have the courage to make choices that may even run counter to strong influences.  In short, courage is required to be an effective citizen, and citizenship education makes citizens “brave and enterprising”.

The strength of our republic depends on the ability of our citizens to participate fully in the decision making process to guide the nation.  Our founders wished its citizens to be capable of distinguishing between fact and fiction, truth and lies.  This cannot be achieved when our citizenry is uninformed about the workings of government and our guiding principles.

In today’s overheated political environment, and with social media’s expansive influence, it is a challenge to sort through the noise.  Even the best informed must wade through the clutter of claims and news stories to reach a clear position.  So much is placed in front of us, we are left to making judgment calls based on our best sense and reason.  The effort required can be daunting even frustrating, but it matters too much to fail to make that effort.  We need to be fully equipped to make judgments that are good for the country.

John Adams said:” Liberty cannot be preserved without a general knowledge among the people”.  Yes, STEM education is very important for our livelihoods, our work days.  But we are citizens ALL of the time.  We need to reestablish the importance of learning the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, and our history.  We can no longer neglect the task of maintaining an informed citizenry. 


Saturday, September 8, 2018

Resistance, reveal thyself!

What does the anonymous letter to the NYT show us about the current state of governing?

Is there a consensus view among senior officials that we have an unfit president, or is this just a small cadre? 

Do our adversaries perceive the US as a distracted nation of dithering nabobs?

What are Congressional leaders doing to find out the depth and magnitude of distress in our executive branch?

Has there been a virtual coup d'etat by (perhaps justifiably) concerned senior officials?

What are the potential reactions from the prez over the revelations in the Woodward book and NYT letter, and what should be done to prepare?

Where are comments from other former presidents that will help us understand the impact of this situation?

Was all the justifiable praise of John McCain about civic virtue mere hypocrisy, a sentimental interlude in the dysfunction of Washington?

etc, etc

This is no way to guide our ship of state.  This end-run around constitutional process is alarming.   

All indicators are flashing "invoke 25th amendment".  ("Impeach" flashers have been ignored by our supine Congress)