Thursday, April 28, 2011

CIA mistake

The CIA director needs to have the full scope of independent judgment. It's a civilian agency which is designed for espionage, not war fighting. So, it is not a good idea to have a uniformed officer at the helm of the CIA.

The president as CinC and a serving general officer as head of CIA makes for a potentially problematic relationship. If the president directs Patreus to do something to which he disagrees, as a uniformed officer he will have to follow orders or resign. Further, it militarizes the CIA in a way that may reduce its effectiveness.

What do you think?

Saturday, April 9, 2011

Shutdown Averted, for now

Is it just me, or are there too many journalists out there? All week long the press has been hammering us with reports about the negotiations to prevent a looming shutdown. Rumor upon innuendo upon speculation. A tidbit here, a fat guess there - nothing really substantive. And what about perspective. The dollars involved represent less than 0.2% of the federal budget. Not even a nano-dent. Rarely did we hear comment on that fact. As usual, our press corps got caught up in the frenzied vortex of what might happen. The distraction was troubling, especially given that we have actual issues that are in process, affecting others, tilting the world dangerously. We would have been just as well off had no reports been given throughout the week. Then, late Friday night, we would hear that "after a week of wrangling, the Congress has reached agreement to avert a government shutdown". That's something worth reporting, instead of the breathless, constant you-know-what-might-happen? George Washington may have had it right when he insisted that the Constitutional Convention meet in secret. Can you imagine the press reports over the 5 months debate - a daily dose of specualtion over what might be. Doubtful it would have gotten done at all. Instead, we have this circus, just one in the many rings of media and press distractions. They're supposed to be better than this.